RNS
Browse Projects > Detailed View

Stormwater Management to Address Highway Runoff Toxicity Associated with Tire Wear

Description:

Recent research findings identified 6PPD-quinone as the major agent responsible for exceptionally high levels of rapid mortality of adult Coho salmon in some urban streams[1]. Lethal effects occurred in Coho at very low concentrations of 6PPD-quinone. Related studies have found the chemical is also toxic to rainbow trout, and King Salmon, and other aquatic species may be at risk as well[2], [3]. So far, the lethal impact, presumably from 6PPD-quinone, has only been documented in urban streams that receive runoff from high average daily traffic (ADT) highways.

6PPD is a chemical added to tires to increase their life by reducing tire oxidation. It has been used for over 40 years in almost all tires and is assumed to be ubiquitous in roadway runoff, as are tire particulates that have been detected in fish across the country[4]. Potential sources of 6PPD-quinone in stormwater include tire wear particulates, abrasion of pavement that contains tire derived aggregate (TDA), and potentially leachate from fill incorporating ground tires. Although standard analytical test methods are not yet available, researchers have detected 6PPD and linked it to toxicity in runoff; standard methods are currently under development by the WA Department of Ecology.

Questions of importance for DOTs are: 1) Under what conditions and where is 6PPD-quinone related toxicity an issue, 2) what highway related and receiving water factors are implicated, and 3) what drainage characteristics and stormwater management techniques are practical (feasible) to build and capable of reducing or eliminating the toxicity of highway runoff due to 6PPD-quinone and other pollutants (zinc, copper, PAHs, etc.).

There are also concerns about use of TDAs in the roadway environment. DOTs and other transportation agencies will be a primary target of regulatory efforts to address 6PPD-quinone toxicity. Projects have already been delayed due to uncertainty as to where, what type, and how much treatment of roadway runoff is necessary.

The research, identified as a priority for a Research Needs Statement by the TRB AKD50 Stormwater Subcommittee, will 1) identify where and what features within the highway environment contribute acutely toxic runoff associated with 6PPD-quonine and 2) identify and develop practical treatment facilities and stormwater management approaches that can be used in urban and rural areas.


[1] Z. Tian et al., Science 10.1126/science.abd6951 (2020). [2] McIntyre, J., Mystery Solved: Tires Kill Coho Salmon, Stormwater Summit, Oregon Association of Clean Water Agencies, May 12th, 2021. [3] Halle, L. L., Palmqvist, A., Kampmann, K., & Khan, F. R. (2020). Ecotoxicology of micronized tire rubber: Past, present and future considerations. Science of the Total Environment, 706, 135694. [4] Xinfeng Zhang et al 2020 IOP Conf. Ser.: Earth Environ. Sci. 555 012062

Objective:

The objective of this research is to identify under what conditions runoff intervention is needed and develop and provide design guidance for stormwater treatment and management techniques that substantially reduce or eliminate highway runoff toxicity, as well as 6PPD-quinone specifically. Toxicity testing is vital because there is no formal toxicity criteria for 6PPD-quonine, and other components of highway runoff likely affect toxicity as well.

Benefits:

The demonstrated toxicity of 6PPD-quinone for at least one listed Threatened and Endangered species and the potential for toxic impacts to other aquatic species[1] means that regulatory agencies will likely impose treatment requirements on highway projects. It may also limit the ability to use recycled tire paving products that meet other agency environmental goals. Permit conditions could include requirements for retrofits as well as new/re-development projects. This research will help inform cost-effective solutions for DOTs to implement as well as appropriate regulatory requirements.

Without this research, regulatory requirements may be based on insufficient information, resulting in overly broad requirements, misapplied and misdirected resources, and implementation of BMPs where they are not necessary and so provide no appreciable benefit, or conversely do not provide sufficient treatment. Also, regulatory requirements may be ad hoc, providing no consistency and creating confusion, inefficiencies and delays.

As a result of this research, DOTs will have the information necessary to better understand where to focus more specific treatment efforts to effectively manage highway runoff for 6PPD-quinone toxicity. Regulatory agencies will have a better understanding of stormwater management options and treatment methods that reduce and/or remove toxicity. Sensitive aquatic species will benefit from reduced toxicity in their environment. Lastly, knowledge regarding the potential release of 6PPD-quinone and its toxicity will help DOTs in selection and placement of paving materials that are composed in part of TDA.


[1] The toxicity of 6PPD-quinone has not been widely tested on most aquatic species, but in addition to Coho Salmon toxicity, it has been identified as toxic to rainbow trout and King Salmon. (see 2 and 3 above).

Related Research:

Only limited research has been published on 6PPD-quinone in stormwater and its toxicity. Initial results indicate that filtration of highway runoff through or contact with bioretention media/compost appears to eliminate lethal toxicity to Coho1,2. Previous research on copper toxicity in highway runoff found that filtration of highway runoff through a biofiltration media significantly reduced toxicity, indicating that the mix is effective in reducing the toxicity of 6PPD-quinone2. This research did not address practical structural BMP design elements nor effects of earthen or vegetated drainage systems. The NCHRP study Environmental Impact of Construction and Repair Materials on Surface and Ground Waters (NCHRP Report 448[1]), found that within a short distance of contacting soils, toxicity from leachate and runoff was significantly reduced. The TRID database includes a few reports on toxicity reduction effectiveness, specifically by filtration through dead vegetation in vegetated ditches and in detention ponds as well. These studies indicate that the drainage conveyance type can play a major role in addressing potential 6PPD-quinione toxicity.


[1] Nelson, P. et. Al., 2001. Environmental Impact of Construction and Repair Materials on Surface and Ground Waters. NCHRP REPORT 448, Project B25-9 FY’94, ISSN 0077-5614, ISBN 0-309-06666-2. 128 pp.

Tasks:

Major tasks or activities:

· Literature review on 1) highway runoff toxicity, with an emphasis on 6PPD-quinone toxicity and 2) effectiveness of treatment and stormwater management, including the effect of vegetated drainage system types on toxicity reduction.

· Field collection of highway runoff and laboratory analyses to:

                 i.     Assess toxicity reduction of high traffic highway runoff routed through bare soil, compost amended soil and vegetated conveyances 

                ii.     Design and conduct a laboratory study to determine filtration material characteristics and mechanisms (such as layer thickness, infiltration rate, contact times, etc.) necessary for effective toxicity and/or 6PPD-quinone concentration reduction by BMPs

              iii.     Conduct selected 6PPD-quinone leachability tests for tire derived aggregate/crumb rubber containing pavement materials

· Identify the components and features of the highway system and receiving waters that affect 6PPD-quinone toxicity and its impacts.

Deliverables: A report that provides 1) guidance on identifying situations where 6PPD-quinone targeted BMPs are appropriate to avoid toxic impacts, 2) an initial assessment of the potential for TDAs to contribute to toxicity, and 3) design criteria for 6PPD-quinone targeting BMPs. Research documenting toxicity reductions by drainage systems and BMPs etc. should be prepared for peer reviewed publication.

Implementation:

Stormwater engineers and environmental staff, including water resources specialists and biologists, will benefit from applying the research results and recommendations. Pavement engineering staff will also benefit from assessment of TRD paving materials and fill. State DOTs can implement the research within their own organization by utilizing the site selection and design guidance developed by the project. The content could be included in Hydrology and Hydraulics manuals or via technical bulletins so implementation would not likely require new procedures. Professional conferences, including the Hydrology and Hydraulics conference and the TRB annual meeting, professional peer reviewed and trade publications, and webinars could be used to support implementation.

Statement reviewed and submitted on behalf of the TRB Committee on Hydrology, Hydraulics and Stormwater (AKD50). Contact: Michael Perez, mike.perez@auburn.edu, (334) 844-6267. The proposal is co-sponsored by TRB Committee on Environmental Analysis and Ecology in Transportation (AEP70). Contact: Daniel Smith, Daniel.Smith@ucf.edu, (386) 785-1565. The proposal is also endorsed by the AASHTO Technical Committee on Hydrology and Hydraulics. State and federal natural resource and regulatory agencies (such as California Department of Toxic Substances Control) would likely be highly interested in this research.

Sponsoring Committee:AEP70, Environmental Analysis and Ecology
Research Period:24 - 36 months
Research Priority:High
RNS Developer:• William Fletcher, Independent (retired Oregon DOT), (503) 679-4160, svartstone2@yahoo.com • Eric Strecker, PE, Terraphase Engineering Inc., (503) 889-0367 ext. 66, eric.strecker@terraphase.com
Date Posted:09/20/2021
Date Modified:10/19/2021
Index Terms:Runoff, Water pollution, Tires, Water quality management,
 
Subjects    
Environment

Please click here if you wish to share information or are aware of any research underway that addresses issues in this research needs statement. The information may be helpful to the sponsoring committee in keeping the statement up-to-date.